We have a job applicant who worked for us for about a year approximately five years ago. There’s nothing negative in her file, but neither of her former supervisors wants to hire her back, saying that she was not a good worker. She has applied several times and each time has received a rejection letters, but she keeps reapplying. Can we ask her to stop submitting applications?

Posted  03-14-2012

Ann Kiernan replies:

As far as I know, you can’t stop someone from applying for a job. Your best course of action is to continue to follow your job-posting and application-review procedures and treat her the same way you treat other applicants. Of course, you should hire the most qualified person who will be the best fit for the job and the company. Here, the main reason for not hiring the applicant is her earlier unsatisfactory work performance. Unfortunately, it seems that her former supervisors didn’t appropriately evaluate her performance or document her file. I’m also assuming that there’s no documentation indicating she isn’t eligible for rehire. And, the supervisors’ failure to document the employee’s poor performance may also be one reason she keeps applying for a job. If she was never disciplined for or counseled about her poor job performance, she may well believe she was a good worker. You may want to take this opportunity to educate the employee’s former supervisors – and all supervisors and managers – on the importance of managing and documenting employee performance.


Information here is correct at the time it is posted. Case decisions cited here may be reversed. Please do not rely on this information without consulting an attorney first.